We use Cookies – by using this site or closing this message you’re agreeing to our Cookie Policy.

AUTOWEB.co.uk

Top Info Across the Auto Web

Jeep Grand Cherokee V6 CRD vs. Range Rover Sport TDV6 SE

jeep grand cherokee v6 crd

Jeep Grand Cherokee V6 CRD

 

With fuel prices the way they are, it simply doesn't make sense to buy a 4x4 with a huge petrol engine. UK motorists will get far better usage out of a strong diesel engine, because not only will it deliver better fuel economy, but diesel powered cars hold their value better and are more suited to the point of the vehicle.

At £49,495 on the road, the top specification diesel powered Jeep Grand Cherokee is a direct alternative to the £51,550 Range Rover Sport TDV6. To the clued in motorist, the Range Rover is the better all-rounder, but it's fair to say that the Grand Cherokee has a few neat tricks up its sleeve that run Jaguar Land Rover's offering very close indeed.

Firstly, the Jeep Grand Cherokee is stunning to look at. Opinions are divided about the front end of this car, but I think it's more than capable of putting up a fight against the Range Rover. With a familiar rectangular split mesh grill, narrow headlights, a chunky body kit and dual rectangular exhaust tips at the back, the Grand Cherokee looks like it means business. The profile is completed with fat rubber and ride height that sees it sit slightly higher than the Sport, and from the driver's seat, you feel like you have considerable road presence.

Inside, the new Grand Cherokee is MUCH improved on the older model. An all new dashboard design and cabin design rival that of the Range Rover, and all switch gear is of a comparable quality. The leather seats are soft, comfortable and supportive, and there is a lot of room for driver, passenger and rear occupants to get comfortable in. Make no mistake - the Grand Cherokee is an incredibly spacious car. The interior design is smart with an aluminium fascia for the centre console, leather and soft touch dashboard leather steering wheel, and the door cards have even been lined with leather. The result is an exceptionally premium interior that is geared more towards comfort than sportiness.

Fire the Grand Cherokee up, and the 246 bhp 3.0-litre turbo-diesel V6 gives off a very nice tone indeed, so nice in fact that I wondered if it was a petrol at first, Vibration transferred through to the cabin is minimal and on the move, the car is incredibly gutsy, with lots of mid-range to hurl you along. By comparison, the TDV6 in the Range Rover produces 254 bhp. Although I tested the more powerful of V6 diesel engines in the Jeep, there is also a lesser 188 bhp version available, which offers better fuel economy.

Speaking of which, I managed to return 37.5 mpg on a combined run in the Grand Cherokee. Now that's impressive for a car this big.

Ultimately, the Grand Cherokee is a fine car, but it's more geared towards comfort and seriousness than the Range Rover Sport. It is recommended, therefore, for anybody who wants something different.

 

range rover sport tdv6

Range Rover Sport TDV6

 

Range Rover Sport TDV6 SE is the lowest specification Range Rover your money can buy. It rolls in at £51,550 on the road, which is more expensive than the impressive Jeep Grand Cherokee. So is it better?

Well, yes, it is, but these are two very different cars in terms of driving dynamic.

I'll start by talking about the way the all new Range Rover Sport drives - it is lighter than the outgoing model, and the TDV6 engine has been refined to deliver torque lower down the rev range and better fuel economy. The result is a car that is light years ahead over the older Sport, but just slightly ahead of the Jeep Grand Cherokee. Plant the throttle, and you can reach 62 mph in just 7.1 seconds in the sport versus 8.2 seconds in the Grand Cherokee. This is party down to the cars added bhp, but also because the Sport is lighter.

This lighter frame really defines how the Sport drives - it is so easy to push hard and in the corners, it can take you around bends much faster than you might think. The 4 wheel drive system is, I'd say, as good as the Grand Cherokees although sadly I did not get to test either off road to see which is best. Both engines develop plenty of torque and both all wheel drive systems are very clever, though, so I'd expect them to be equal.

Inside, the Range Rover Sport is a gorgeous place to be. Leather is everywhere you look and every single switch and button you could possible need is within easy reach. The ergonomics of the dashboard are, I'd say, better than the Jeep's and in terms of interior quality, I'd say the Sport edges the Grand Cherokee in that department too. The Jeep is a wonderful place to be but the Range Rover just feels more special, and the sportiness of some of the trim really helps to bring the character of the Range Rover out.

I carried out two trips in both the Range Rover and Jeep and returned fuel economy figures that rivalled one another - as noted above, I got 37.5 mpg out of the Jeep, and I got 34.8 mpg out of the Range Rover. My two trips involved motorway driving, town driving, and B road blasting. I was impressed with both cars and the way in which they sip fuel. A couple of times I was in fact astonished due to the sheer size of these beasts.

Ultimately, the Range Rover Sport is the more desirable car of the two. BUT, whilst it's more sporty and luxurious inside, it is a couple of thousand pounds more expensive, and opinions are divided over which one is the better looking car.

If I was forced to choose with a gun to my head, though, it'd have to be the Range Rover.

 

Share this Article

Please rate this article

(Average rating: 4 , Total rates: 6 )

Please Enter Your Comment

Anonymous